Rosario Dawson Gabbie Chase W. Dillon Travis Lakeith Stanfield Ben Matthias Owen Wilson Father Kent Tiffany Haddish Harriet Danny DeVito Bruce Davis Jared Leto The Hatbox Ghost Jamie Lee Curtis Madame Leota J.R. Adduci William Gracey Creek Wilson Mariner Ghost Lindsay Lamb The Bride Charity Jordan Alyssa Fedor Steer Ezra Terence Rosemore Phineas Mike Benitez Gus Erika Coleman Eleanor Gracey Christopher Winchester New Year's Eve Bartender Jo Koy Daytime Bartender Gralen Bryant Banks Drunk Man Marilu Henner Carol Tourist Steve Zissis Roger Andrew Morgado TV Narrator (voice) Amy Parrish Doctor Kurt Yue Police Officer Hasan Minhaj Sketch Artist Dan Levy Vic Sebastien Soudais Duelist John Curran Pickwick Tracy Goode Executioner Bryan McClure Headless Knight Don Stallings Venetian Ghost Rick Andosca Caretaker Ghost Kamran Shaikh Suited Man on Dynamite Jared Simon Hatted Man in Quicksand Kay Galvin Elderly Woman w/Rose Winona Ryder Pat (uncredited)